Sanju Samson's place in India's T20I setup has once again come under intense scrutiny after another disappointing outing, with former India all-rounder Irfan Pathan identifying a recurring technical flaw in the wicketkeeper-batter's game. At the same time, the clamour for teenage batting sensation Vaibhav Sooryavanshi to receive an opportunity at the highest level has grown louder, creating fresh selection debates ahead of India's upcoming matches.
Samson has long been regarded as one of India's most naturally gifted stroke-makers. His elegant cover drives, fearless six-hitting ability, and versatility against both pace and spin have made him a fan favourite. However, despite possessing immense talent, the Kerala batter has struggled to convert opportunities into consistent performances in international cricket.
The latest criticism followed Samson's failure in the opening T20I against England. With India looking for a positive start, the experienced batter was unable to make an impact, adding to concerns over his inconsistent run in the shortest format. While poor scores are part of every cricketer's journey, what has worried experts is the manner of his dismissals.
Former India cricketer Irfan Pathan believes Samson's problem is more technical than mental. According to Pathan, Samson often allows the ball to travel too close to his body while attempting attacking shots outside the off stump. This leaves him vulnerable against disciplined seam bowling, especially during the powerplay when bowlers exploit movement and bounce.
Pathan explained that modern T20 cricket demands aggressive intent, but aggression must be backed by sound technique. Repeatedly falling to similar deliveries suggests that opposition teams have identified a clear weakness and are executing well-planned strategies against Samson. Unless those technical issues are addressed, teams are likely to continue targeting the same areas.
The criticism has sparked widespread discussion among fans and former players alike. Many believe Samson deserves a longer run in the side because of his proven ability to win matches single-handedly. Others argue that international cricket offers limited opportunities and that players must deliver consistently when selected.
Adding further pressure is the emergence of Vaibhav Sooryavanshi. At just 15 years of age, the left-handed batter has become one of India's brightest young prospects. His fearless stroke play, remarkable composure, and record-breaking performances for India A have made him one of the most talked-about young cricketers in the country.
Sooryavanshi recently grabbed headlines by smashing one of the fastest List A fifties in history before narrowly missing out on a century. His ability to dominate quality bowling attacks at such a young age has convinced many experts that he possesses the temperament required for international cricket.
Although the selectors included him in India's squad, the youngster was left out of the playing XI for the first T20I, with the team management opting for experience. However, after India's top-order struggles, social media was flooded with calls demanding Sooryavanshi's debut.
The debate, however, is not necessarily about replacing Samson with Sooryavanshi. The two batters have different roles and bring contrasting strengths to the side. Samson is an experienced wicketkeeper-batter capable of accelerating in the middle order, while Sooryavanshi is an aggressive top-order batter who naturally attacks from the very first ball.
India's management therefore faces a difficult balancing act. On one hand, backing experienced players through lean patches is often essential for long-term success. On the other, ignoring a young player in exceptional form could mean delaying the development of a future superstar.
Head coach and selectors have repeatedly emphasized that performances in domestic cricket and India A tours will be rewarded. If that policy remains consistent, Sooryavanshi's opportunity may not be far away. The teenager has shown remarkable maturity beyond his years and appears mentally prepared for the challenges of international cricket.
For Samson, the road ahead is equally important. Few doubt his talent, but international cricket demands adaptation. Addressing the technical concerns highlighted by Irfan Pathan could help the wicketkeeper-batter rediscover the consistency that has often eluded him. Small adjustments in footwork, shot selection, and decision-making during the powerplay could significantly improve his effectiveness.
Competition for places in India's T20I batting lineup has never been stronger. Alongside established names like Yashasvi Jaiswal, Shubman Gill, Suryakumar Yadav, Tilak Varma, Rinku Singh, and Ishan Kishan, emerging talents such as Vaibhav Sooryavanshi are constantly pushing for opportunities.
This depth is ultimately a positive sign for Indian cricket. Healthy competition ensures that every player is motivated to improve while giving selectors multiple options depending on conditions and opposition.
As India continue their T20I campaign, every innings will carry extra significance. Samson will be eager to silence his critics with a match-winning performance, while Sooryavanshi will hope patience eventually gives way to opportunity.
Whether the team management continues backing experience or decides to inject fresh energy into the batting lineup remains to be seen. One thing is certain—the conversation surrounding Sanju Samson's technique and Vaibhav Sooryavanshi's selection is unlikely to fade anytime soon.
With major ICC tournaments on the horizon, every performance will influence selection decisions. India's think tank must strike the right balance between nurturing emerging talent and maintaining faith in experienced campaigners. If Samson rediscovers his best form, he could remain a vital part of India's plans. If not, the door could soon open for one of the country's most exciting teenage talents.